2nd Post - Nick

It was a pretty boring story. There was no action. The only good parts were extremely short. There wasn't any excitement. I like mystery and action books. I liked some of the characters. The main character was brave so i liked him. I liked the lieutenant in the story. He was responsible and smart. I didn't like Shelp because he ran away and abandoned his army. The fighting didn't take place in the story which made the book more uninteresting. It would have been a good book if there was some action it it.